Yves here. This post is a useful counterpoint to our piece today on rising levels of psychological distress….often for entirely rational reasons. Being in nature, even short walks in green areas, has been found to reduce anxiety and increase the sense of well being. Teaching children in outdoor settings gives them different skills, not just ones like gardening or hiking or camping, but also potentially citizen science capabilities, such as close observation and information-gathering. Having competencies in more settings also can increase confidence levels.
And that’s before getting to the possibility that “living off the land” skills might well become very useful.
By Damon Orion, a writer, journalist, musician, artist, and teacher in Santa Cruz, California. His work has appeared in Revolver, Guitar World, Spirituality + Health, Classic Rock, and other publications. Read more of his work at DamonOrion.com.Produced by Local Peace Economy
Author, journalist, and child advocacy expert Richard Louv famously coinedthe term “nature deficit disorder” to describe the detrimental effects of children’s disconnection from nature. His assertions are backed by data that strongly suggests a link between increased exposure to nature and improved cognitive function, brain activity, and mental and physical health.
Paraphrasing Louv, nature schoolteacher Angela Garcia notes, “America is completely deficient in Vitamin N: Vitamin Nature.”
Garcia is the co-director of True Roots Nature School Program, a Santa Cruz, California-based outdoor education curriculum for children ages 18 months to 12 years old. Designed to provide all the benefits of indoor education while enriching the experience with nature immersion, this program “takes place on private property in the Santa Cruz Mountains in addition to field trip locations,” the school’s website states.
In the U.S., schools focusing on reconnecting children with nature have seen a marked increase in enrollment since 2020. For example, the LiberatED Podcast reports that Barefoot University Forest School “started with just a handful of families in the Dallas/Fort Worth area of Texas” in 2019 “and has now grown to serve more than 3,000 students nationwide.” Meanwhile, a 2022 national survey from the Natural Start Alliance found “an estimated 800 nature preschools in the United States, up more than 200 percent from 2017.”
A key reason for this shift is that outdoor schools present a reasonably safealternative to online learning, which dominated the education world during the COVID-19 pandemic. “It was pretty difficult when all the schools in California shifted straight to [Zoom classes],” Garcia says. “I thought that was a little bit unfortunate, especially because there’s so much innovation [in this state], and we could easily move desks outdoors.”
Ian Abraham is the head of Oregon’s Portland Forest School, which “blends academics with hands-on learning” for K–eighth grade students. He believes the pandemic prompted parents to “see things through a different lens,” giving them “an opportunity to see that there might be something to their child learning out of doors in a more immersive, experiential environment.”
A 2023 study published in Frontiers in Psychology also points out how outdoor learning can boost motivation, engagement, communication, collaboration, critical thinking, and creativity.
Contrasting outdoor education with indoor schooling, Garcia says, “You can read a story about a woodpecker many times throughout the school year, but reading a story in front of an old oak tree while a woodpecker is pecking the tree next to you is an unbelievable experience. For kids to see what they’re reading in real life makes the learning experience incredible.”
Abraham recalls a project in which the members of a second-grade class broke into small groups, with each group searching for a different type of mushroom. After reconverging, the students sorted the mushrooms by species category based on morphology. Then they used the mushrooms as part of a math lesson. “The students were numbering, counting, and adding or subtracting to the piles of different kinds of mushrooms,” he explains.
Out With the Old, In With the Older
While Abraham sees the current outdoor education boom as a modern movement, he also feels this approach is “inherently old in so many ways. What we’re doing in our school is almost a [remembrance] of how things were before institutionalized education. This is how we have learned for tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, of years. The combination of experiential [learning] and academics is helping parents remember that there’s something inherent to this that speaks well to a child’s development.”
Garcia notes, “I think there’s a general movement right now for some alternative ways of raising children. In our country, many people want to grow and make their own food and go outdoors with their children. If you look, [many] tech CEOs don’t send their children to schools with a lot of technology. We have to question: Why is that? It [is because it] stunts growth.”
She adds that there is a time and place for technology in education. “I don’t want my children or students to be completely inept at learning the technology around them. However, let’s say we’re doing a STEM skillactivity, but you’re building on an iPad with your finger: What about using your hands and fine motor skills [by] building with popsicle sticks or sticks in the forest? There’s a major difference there [in terms of how you concentrate] and the way your brain works if you’re doing puzzles with your hands versus on a screen. There’s a lot of different learning using tactile objects or even just using a drill and screws versus creating something technologically.”
Like True Roots, Portland Forest School emphasizes the benefits of nature immersion on cognition and overall health. This includes relief from the harmful effects of excessive exposure to the electronic world.
“It seems like new studies come out on a three-or-four-month cycle about our anxious generation, the connection [of that] to social media, the lack of connection to self and people around us, and the literal brain chemistry changes that are happening due to the amount of time we are on our screens,” Abraham states.
However, while Abraham observes that decreased screen time “clearly benefits the brain,” he notes that Portland Forest School’s staff members “are not Luddites. I’m constantly on my phone [due to] my job. We have computers and work on assessments and research with Chromebooks at school. Our kids are not walking away wondering [how] to search on Google or how to cite a website.”
Weathering the Elements
True Roots operates rain or shine unless conditions like high winds, storms, intense heat, or poor air quality from smoke present a danger. Portland Forest School functions similarly: The school’s faculty and students spend 85 percent of their time outdoors, with tarps and dry erase boards enabling them to stay outside in rainy weather. Some indoor learning takes place on two small buses that serve as mobile classrooms while transporting attendees to different green spaces throughout Portland. The school also has a building for supplemental education, particularly in math.
“We often joke that we have field trips where we stay inside,” Abraham says. “That happens every so often when the weather is especially bad. Actually, sometimes the kids love it. They think it’s so special and weird: ‘I can take my shoes off? What are we doing?’”
By spending most of their time outdoors, nature school students are learning principles and practices that may prove valuable as the effects of climate change worsen. According to the National Wildlife Federation’s blog, “Across multiple research studies, outdoor education has been found to increase youth environmental sensitivity and stewardship.”
Garcia says True Roots helps instill eco-friendly habits and values. “We bring in a lot of sustainable practices to what we’re doing. We’re not allowed to pick anything or damage the terrain, and we’re trying to [educate] students about respecting the land around us and its importance.”
While Abraham acknowledges that climate change presents an “intense challenge,” he and his colleagues take comfort in “knowing that we’re teaching our kids a strong level of resiliency, adaptability, problem-solving, and resourcefulness.” For example, Portland Forest School’s curriculumincludes “Earth skills” like water quality evaluation, fire safety, resource gathering, and survival strategies.
“Also, our kids inherently [have] love for the natural world, and you tend to want to protect, support, and endorse what you love,” Abraham states. “In all of that, a level of stewardship comes.”
Sounds great. Until you read the fine print :
True Roots Nature School Tuition
2 days per week : $695
3 days per week: $1020
5 days per week : $1660
On the other hand, in Oregon, Measure 99 made outdoor school a right for all 5th and 6th graders. And it is funded.
A ranger friend of mine used to conduct snow school for high school kids of all income levels at Crater Lake National Park. Too bad it was only for a day, but kids learned about snow, ecology, and water hands on and on snowshoes during the class — and the day finished with a high speed penguin slide down a packed snowslope! She deplores the new trend toward classroom nature teaching of “doing science” for kids. While she sees that as important at some stage in their education, kids need to have tangible direct experience of animals, plants, and experience how it fits together in a world. And during my short time as a wildlife field researcher in the Rockies, I discovered that real scientists want to do nothing more than be out in the field. That’s where they bonded with nature, and that’s what led them to become scientists — that’s the power of direct contact with nature.
As a kid, my life was changed as a student and later as a volunteer of the amazing Alexander Lindsay Junior Museum, a municipally owned nature education center. The staff ran inexpensive classes about wildlife and ecology, and one of the first wildlife rescue centers in the country. A bunch of volunteer kids cleaned the floors and cages (the animals in the museum came there as rescue animals that could not be released back into nature) — the older ones got to become Junior Curators. Imagine being a fifteen-year-old in charge of caring for a redtail hawk! It is also interesting that so many girls were the leaders and most competent and trusted Junior Curators, during a time when, in other veunes, their opportunities were limited by sexism. The place changed my life.
Friends just started sending their kid to a Waldorf school, which I believe does something similar although not with outdoor classes all the time. Lots of animals, learning traditional skills like sewing, etc. They noted a dramatic improvement in their daughter’s overall demeanor – she really took to it. It sounded like a really good program, but I think those schools are also very pricey.
Right. Nature as luxury good.
But that doesn’t mean the ideas advocated above are wrong, whatever the practicalities of fulfilling them.As a compromise we can have some urban nature provided to the public as common space that costs nothing to visit. Towns like mine are increasingly seeing the virtue of this whereas before they saw such areas as wasted space not pulling its weight as taxable land.
And there’s also the question of whether Nature enjoys having us around as much as we enjoy being there. Maybe the woodpecker would just as soon not have a bunch of noisy kids at the base of its tree. Wildlife has its own practicalities.
But on a personal level I very much agree with the above and practice what it preaches.
Spouse’s 3rd grader grandnephew [he calls me “gruncle”] attends a school of this sort in Minnesota – it seems like great fun and great preparation for a future of who knows what.
His cousin, five years old in a South American country, just got her “tiger belt” in tae kwon do.
As the new year approaches I try to accept each day as it comes, keeping in mind Lawrence Berra’s observation that “you never know when something surprising might happen”.
Teach kids about him and let them have fun playing around with his quotes:
When you get to the fork in the trail, take it.
I was fortunate that my parents loved the outdoors, and practically pushed me in that direction, and its a world where money holds little sway (with the exception of the ‘outdoor’ schools mentioned) and everything is inherently honest, AI doesn’t mean squat, everything is unscripted… life happens as it were~
It’s funny the way they’re saying they’re no Luddites… I recall having an entire education without cellphones or the internet… as does everyone else who worked to develop these things. A chalk board, pens, paper and books can work just as well… just ask Newton or Gauss.
I do wonder though whether the inhumane way in which the young are brought up (no windows in class, no nature, etc) isn’t a means to make them dissatisfied, so that they become model consumers.
As an educator, I am trying to remove online activities completely from my curriculum. The cell phones still pull them back, as the dopamine addiction is real.
Agreed regarding the remark about Luddites. Genuine historical context aside, it’s a remark that speaks to the insecurities of older people who chronically worry about the world leaving them behind…and their kids, too!
Here in Canada there are schools actually situated within nature, imagine that! And rural schools! And they’re just ordinary public schools, not private or special in any way. And they make use of it with nature-oriented curriculum. What (good) science, biology or art teacher can resist taking advantage of the perfect laboratory or studio? I can even see how a history, math, language or home ec teacher can make use of the surroundings. Of course, the more you get into the city, the more removed from the natural world.
I raised two kids born in Santa Cruz 1994-2013 and was intimately adjacent to the extortionate “alternative school” scene there, where recent-transplant tech-bros and trust-funders could send their perfect DNA-dumplings to be coddled while they rustled their latest start-ups. The Santa Cruz Mountains can be pretty inhospitable in winter, let me assure you!
Most of the “alternative school” kids eventually burned-out and gravitated to the massive open-air meth-and-heroin (now fentanyl) markets also endemic to the woods and meadows surrounding the place, where they could continue to live in the bliss they had been taught to seek. I moved somewhere where I can actually be in nature, away from the methy surf-nazis and urban-outdoorsmen who form the underbelly of the natural beauty of the place…
we have Decolonize Academy here, very similar concepts in an urban environment. Activism a major part of the curriculum. Parents pay what they can. the school is always struggling but they care and show lots of love to the kids.